Friday, September 21, 2012

Glimmers of Hope?


From T.:
A few weeks ago, I was on my way to a meeting and attempted to get out of the Metro system via the New York Avenue station. I live in Virginia and am served primarily by the Orange Line (which, for what it's worth, has a whole litany of problems) but I always cringe twice as hard when I find out I need to use the Red Line. This time, the ride went pretty smoothly but I experienced a minor setback when my DumbTrip card balked and asked me to solicit some help from the station manager.

D'oh...

The last time I sought help from a station manager to resolve an unrelated matter, it didn't go well. This time, however, the manager on duty that day in the New York Avenue station could not have been nicer. She promptly recused herself from a conversation with a coworker and opened the kiosk door to ask me what was wrong. Her responses were friendly and she didn't show signs of exasperation, even after I had to go up and bug her again twice more because the card was still so uncooperative. When all was said and done, she smiled, saluted me and wished me a great day. I thanked her profusely and proceeded to go about my business. Had some thoughtless young girl not spilled part of her mocha latte on me as we approached Gallery Place on the way back, it would have been a perfect ride. This is why I keep a spare clean suit in my office.

But, wait, there's more!

After a year and a half of heavy usage, I decided it was time to replace my aging DumbTrip card, given what happened at New York Avenue. It always helps to have a backup on hand (friends don't let friends be seen in public with paper fare cards) and, plus, there's a commuter store right above my home station in Ballston. The woman inside was on the phone when I approached, but she placed the other party on hold when she saw me park myself in front of the glass, which was very refreshing. I've been "placed on in-person hold" more often than I'd like to admit as the person behind the desk prattles away on the phone. She even waived the $0.25 "convenience fee" for me when I told her I didn't have an extra quarter. Class act, madam!

So, station manager and commuter store attendant, I commend you both for reminding me that there's a reason why I use public transportation. I wish I'd have thought to ask for your names so I could sing your praises all over the Internet. As for you, coffee girl, the fact that you were so sincerely apologetic made it impossible for me to hate you. You might be a little clumsy, but it was early and you may have been still waking up. You're probably not a bad person. I still stand by my statement that it's my biggest pet Metro peeve and, since you were actively drinking it while the train was in motion, I'm still not sorry for reporting you to the train operator. I doubt he ended up doing anything about it, anyway.

In closing, the Metro's been straddling the line between maddening and FUBAR for some time now. I've been subjected to countless sardine trains, stuck in a tunnel for nearly an hour and I even came close to getting robbed at L'Enfant once. (Thankfully, the nature of my employment requires that I maintain a permit to carry a concealed weapon. I'm not afraid to smack someone with the butt end of it.) In spite of Metro's shortcomings and caveats, of which there are many, the best I can do is to try to keep an open mind while riding the rails. Sometimes, it pays off.

Other items:
There really isn't anything Metro can't screw up (WaPo)
Group sues Metro for postponing anti-jihad ads (Examiner)
A brief interview with his Sarlesness (FixWMATA)

Comments (27)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Ever n Astonished's avatar

Ever n Astonished · 653 weeks ago

How heartening. Love it. I, too, now often experience more positive than negative experiences with metro staff at Orange line stations. Wonder if they realize it is impressive to see them act so professionally when working for a completely FUBAR unprofessional company?
Hope and Change? Yeah, that really worked out well for the country in 2008.
1 reply · active 653 weeks ago
Beats greed and opportunism. I'm sure King Mitt has your best interests at heart.
Faith in metro: Restored... Just kidding.
4 replies · active 652 weeks ago
Kid Charlemagne's avatar

Kid Charlemagne · 653 weeks ago

The drinking coffee thing on the Metro is epidemic. They might as well not have a rule. No one follows it.
And it's really been a recent change. 10-15 years ago, no one drank their coffee on the metro for fear of being arrested. Or maybe now there are more coffee places around to pick up your coffee on your way in to work.
There are certainly more places.

But my guess: Every time things went bad during the enforcement of those laws (not merely rules) and some "goodie-two-shoes" got arrested for eating/ drinking in the system, the media couldn't wait to vilify the Transit Police and toss the officer and/or MTPD as a whole under the bus. Things changed after the famous "French Fry Incident." I've asked officers about the present day (lack of) enforcement and have gotten the impression that the department didn't back them up properly (even though the officers involved were acting on complaints from citizens regarding the out of control knucklehead school kids acting-a-fool and EATING on the train!) and as such will only enforce the most egregious violations involving juveniles. They say they'll verbally tell them to put the crap away, and maybe issue a written warning, but after the media and public outcry over "poor lil' Junior" getting arrested for "only eating" that you pretty much get what you get anymore. Of course, priorities have changed after 9/11, too.
I dunno...my and my friends' eating/drinking in the Metro, whether real (actually consuming something) or potential (entering the Metro with a drink or food) have been addressed in recent memory by station managers, other Metro employees, and police. While I do think that's it's appropriate for any of the above to give a polite warning first (unless someone is actively spilling stuff all over the car, the results of saying "you can't eat/drink in here, please put that away/seal it up" are the same as arresting someone, until the violator refuses to do so), I have not experienced any slack or difference in attitude over my last 10 years of riding Metro. I guess I appreciate a good "random, unprovoked arrest" story once in a while to give something to keep the tourists in check (someone who NEVER rides public transit is at far greater risk of spilling stuff all over me than an experienced rider), but, yeah, I do think it's a waste of resources to arrest, process, and ultimately fine someone for eating or drinking who would have stopped doing so had they been politely informed that they needed to stop doing so.
Always nice to hear GOOD NEWS about Metro Employees, there are a few good ones in the "system".

As for your "spiller", I still think ALL STATION MANAGERS need to pick a day, and all stand at the entrances to Metro Stations, Trash cans at the ready, and inform all passengers to dispose of beverages and food before they enter the system!!!!
3 replies · active 652 weeks ago
You know, honestly, it's rare that I see station managers hiding in their little kiosk lately. Something happened -- they're trying to change perceptions.
Bitter Brew's avatar

Bitter Brew · 653 weeks ago

There is no rule against carrying food and beverages onto the Metro that would require their disposal. The rule prohibits consuming them on the Metro. Unfortunately, even if they have beverages in an appropriately sealed container, people can stumble and accidentally spill as the trains jerk their way into stations under manual operation.
Yep, Brew is right. It's perfectly legal to carry food and beverages onto the Metro, just not to consume them. While I *guess* open beverages could be enforced (although I do think a sealed container should be fine...oh, I didn't finish my soda/water/whatever before getting on, why should I have to throw it away before getting on so long as I keep it sealed up?), since I do my GROCERY SHOPPING via Metro, I would throw a hissy fit if the rule were "no food or beverage, open or not." This is a city...even if I had a car, there are times that it is more convenient to use Metro to run to the store. If you couldn't bring any food or beverage onto the Metro, sealed, never open, etc., then we'd be precluding a lot of people from completing their errands, and making those errands a lot less convenient for many others.
There is a very small percentage of Metro employees that are not morons. You found two in a row. Amazing.
Fed Up Rider's avatar

Fed Up Rider · 653 weeks ago

I work at a federal agency near the NY Ave Station and have found the station managers and employees at that stop to be extraordinarily friendly and helpful. They frequently stand by the gates during rush hour, always say hello, and drop whatever they are doing to help people. I truly wish we could clone them because they are, unfortunately, the exception rather than the rule when it comes to Metro.
4 replies · active 652 weeks ago
i'm going to hazard a guess i know which agency it is, so i suspect most of y'all are armed. i think that explains the attitude of WMATA employees at that station. :-)
Fed Up Rider's avatar

Fed Up Rider · 653 weeks ago

HA! That made me (and a few of my colleagues) spit out our coffee. And as much as I don't blame you for thinking that our "accessories" have something to do with it, I really do find the station managers at NY Avenue to be VERY different than other Metro employees I have met.
Sounds like Bizarro Land Metro to me!
"T" is clearly inebriated.
1 reply · active 652 weeks ago
Haha! Well, James, you're half right. While I wasn't inebriated on the day in question, I try to make that happen whenever I'm riding for non-work-related purposes.
What goes unmentioned is that the new smartrip machine in Ballston has never worked.
1 reply · active 653 weeks ago
None of them anywhere are in service yet. Stay tuned.....
"...maintain a permit to carry a concealed weapon."

In D.C.?? How does that happen??!!
2 replies · active 652 weeks ago
My bad, that should have appeared as a link. Technically, you aren't supposed bring them in to DC over the VA state line...
Have the Smarttrip cards become less reliable recently? I have had mine for over 5 years, and all of its malfunctions can be squarely blamed on the gates (it'll work on one end and not the other, for weeks at a time and then suddenly not...and the station managers can't find anything wrong with it when they scan it). It's even survived being irradiated when I mailed it into work one time (it slightly yellowed from that, but still worked). If they're regularly dying after a year and a half nowadays, we either need a major discount or better cards.
I have to say, I've had a couple of good experiences with metro employees lately too. It's weird and surreal when it happens! I was on a broken train where the driver gave us updates with time estimates every 90 seconds and apologized profusely. It was so much less frustrating knowing what was happening. The the station manager at the Federal Center SW station was standing by the gates one evening saying hello to everyone and being really friendly. It was shockingly nice....

Post a new comment

Comments by

 
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License.
Site Meter