Monday, September 10, 2012

Rush Plus Update: Basics Botched


From anonymous:
This Blue Line rider is just loving Rush+. Every morning at Franconia-Springfield is a wonderful adventure.

When you get to the platform, there are often two trains waiting for you. On really boring days, both trains have the correct signage on them, and there is no confusion about which train to board. But who wants THAT?

Fortunately, Metro has recognized that throwing a little whimsy into our mornings will make us much sharper in the day ahead, so the boring scenario described above hardly ever happens.

Usually, the trains bear no signage at all, so one has to either make an educated (and most likely incorrect) guess as to which is a Yellow Line train and which is Blue.

Sometimes, there is a station manager or train conductor voice “clarifying” the issue over the intercom, but it’s often hard to tell to which the train the voice is referring.

Occasionally, a WMATA employee will walk down the platform pointing out which train is which, but if you’re not around for that, you’re just clueless and completely dependent on your fellow travelers (who may have gotten conflicting or incomplete information).

A third scenario has the trains (or electronic signs on each side of the platform) bearing the name of either the Yellow or Blue line, making the rider think s/he is in the right place, only to have this switch shortly before the train leaves. I can’t count how many times I’ve watched would-be Yellow Line riders gape in surprise as the train they thought was theirs pull away.

I have heard that sometimes it’s difficult to get the signs on the trains (I forget the terminology) correct. If that’s the case, WMATA needs to have an employee on the platform pointing people in the right direction.

It would seem to me that getting the signage correct is the most basic and easy thing to accomplish to make Rush+ work smoothly.

Of all the things I feared coming into this change, never did I expect this sort of confusion. (I know, my mistake.) I expected crowds, of course, and increased distances between trains far beyond the planned 12 minutes. But I didn’t think I’d have to play a guessing game each morning. Yes, all this Blue liner needs to do is transfer if I accidentally find myself on a Yellow Line train, but my concern lies more with the folks who keep missing their Yellow Line trains for no good reason.

Oh, and I did email Metro commenting on this issue several weeks back. I received a form response, and if anything, the problem has only gotten worse.
Other items:
Sarles says this, riders say that (WaPo)

Comments (20)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
The good: This morning, they had a WMATA employee at the bottom of the escalator pointing people in the right direction. The bad: Once the Yellow line train left, he started telling people that the next Yellow line would be leaving in 17 minutes. Technically true, but anyone unfamiliar with the system would wait on the platform unnecessarily, instead of hopping on the Blue line train and transferring at King.

A step in the right direction to have someone out there to be sure, but it would be great if that someone could communicate all the options.
1 reply · active 654 weeks ago
(Sorry -- meant to clarify in the above post that I get on at Franconia-Springfield, like today's poster.)
In the WaPo letter, the writer suggests having station managers roam the station. Unfortunately, they have to be in the kiosk or close by because SmarTrip cards constantly screw up and have to be reset.

This is a common theme for Metro suggestions though. You see some problem and think that there is a solution. However, that solution creates an even bigger problem due to some other Metro failure.
Robert Smith's avatar

Robert Smith · 654 weeks ago

Sounds familiar to my experience at Greenbelt. I boarded a waiting train, which the station sign said was the next to leave the platform. However, two green line trains came and left before my yellow line train left the station. Wasn't a big deal, but frustrating for a long-time rider. I can't imagine the havoc for people who aren't familiar with Metro. I think the problem is that Metro was bad at communication before--now that it's more complicated, they're still horrible--which leaves a lot of people dazed and confused on the platforms.
5 replies · active 654 weeks ago
why would you wait for a yellow line train at greenbelt instead of hopping on the green and changing at one of the transfer stations (assuming you are going somewhere on the yellow line that a green line train doesn't).
Bitter Brew's avatar

Bitter Brew · 654 weeks ago

If Robert Smith arrives when there's no Green Line train on the platform, of course he gets on the "next train to leave," which happens to be the Yellow Line train he's looking for.
Frequent red liner's avatar

Frequent red liner · 654 weeks ago

If you are going south of l'enfant plaza, I could understand waiting for a yellow to take me straight to my destination as opposed to getting on a green and transferring. If I'm not in a hurry, I'd prefer a transfer free ride. In the morning, it's great to have a chance to relax and read. I do it all the time coming back from pentagon city to get to metro center. Even if the yellow line will be there only a minute after the blue line, and the yellow line gets back downtown faster, a transfer free ride is nice. It only sucks if (who am I kidding, when,) your train is offloaded, and you think about how you could have been on the one in front.
Why would he transfer at Mt Vernon if he can get a seat at Greenbelt all the way to his Yellow Line destination?
I hear you! Train signage wrong at Rosslyn few days ago. As newbie rider I didn't get on. Yep, it was the correct train. Metro Fails.
curious george's avatar

curious george · 654 weeks ago

West bound orange line to Largo at Rossyln this morning. No clue where t was really going.
My sympathies to my fellow Metro travelers at Franconia-Springfield. I take the Orange Line from Vienna to Foggy Bottom in the morning. While there is no confusion at Vienna about which train to take, the "extra" trains just lead to greater bottlenecks approaching the Rosslyn tunnel. Ironically, it now takes longer to get to DC from Vienna than it did before the service was "improved."
Danny Boy's avatar

Danny Boy · 654 weeks ago

You got to work today, didn't you? You're welcome.
"Fortunately, Metro has recognized that throwing a little whimsy into our mornings will make us much sharper in the day ahead..."

Who says the art of sarcasm is dead?

Well done!
I've made that switch a couple of times from Blue to Yellow. I ride Metro frequently and know my way around the system, the problem is I don't know when the Yellow line is going to show up. I work near Union Station so Yellow line is much faster- as long as I don't have to wait 15 minutes for it. Yes, I can make the transfer at King, but I'm the type of rider that once I have a good seat, stay in it, since there are no guarantees on the next train/car. So I've made that switch because the Yellow line shows up- if there was some way they could display when the next yellow line was going to leave I'd probably have just stayed on the platform and waited, but since it could be 2 minutes or 15, I'll hop on the first train that s hows up.
Speaking of the Blue Line, is there any particular reason besides Metro ineptitude for the fact that in the evenings at least, there will be two Blue Line trains 3 minutes apart, followed by a 12 minute gap? Why the hell are they not spaced more evenly?
I think they are doing it on purpose. Really, it's not hard to accurately communicate which train is which, even for metro. I really think that they are *telling* train drivers not to announce which train it is so that people who don't want to have to do the whole switch at L'Enfant plaza will be forced to, because not enough people are willingly changing their commuting behavior for "RushPlus" to work the way they wanted it to. Otherwise, I think the train drivers would be doing a better job of announcing the train destination. Yes, yes, I know this is metro and they're mostly incompetent, but there are some train drivers that don't suck and I really think they are being told to be vague about which train it is.
hrh king friday 13's avatar

hrh king friday 13 · 654 weeks ago

Anagrams for Rush Plus:
Sulphurs
Hurls Pus
Hurls Sup
Hurls Ups
Hurl Puss
Hurl Sups
Lush Spur
Push Slur
Rush Plus
Uh Slurps
I agree with the original writer: it's a crapshoot at Franconia-Springfield on most mornings as we try to figure out which train is which, since they very seldom have any operating signs and only rarely is a Metro employee there to direct people to the right train. The usual result is people getting onto what they think is the correct train ... then comes the announcement ... and there's a mad rush of people between the trains. One morning there was a Metro employee on the platform and people were asking "Blue or Yellow?", to which he would only point to one train and say "Rush-Plus"...which (I think) meant "Yellow," but is pretty much meaningless to a tourist and confusing even to someone like me, who's been riding Metro since the Franconia-Springfield Station opened. It would be such a simple thing to light up the signs or have a uniformed Metro person on the platform, but I've decided neither one is likely to happen.
Now now, we all know those of us who start our day at Franconia-Springfield station really don't count. We on average pay around 15 dollars day to not really exist within the metro system. I like playing which train did I board? Sort of like musical chairs - only we play musical trains. Oops I wanted the blue line -- hop off quick before the doors close!

I've also been on the correct train and at the last minute they switch for whatever reason. Let's face it, it would just be too easy for the customers to have the signage showing on the trains as we board so we know what trains we are entering. But then again I like musical trains.... keeps me agile.

Post a new comment

Comments by

 
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License.
Site Meter