Tuesday, December 7, 2010

Orange Meltdown


From an anonymous reader:

Yesterday morning, I got on the Orange Line at Vienna. As usual, there were only two turnstiles open going into Metro, causing a significant backup. Why they do this, I don't know. But, this is not why my commute sucked more than usual.

The first warning sign was that the operator didn't know what train he was driving or what the next stop was. He sounded young, so I assumed he was new.

Once we got to Dunn Loring, we held as the operator to get the doors closed. Station attendants were running around on the platform trying to help.

After 8 minutes of this, I was certain we were going to offload.

While I am in no way religious, I said a little prayer and explained to whatever deity it is that controls Metro that I had a very busy day at work and a conference call at 9:30. I asked it to please, not let this happen today.

Sure enough, the doors eventually closed, and the operator announced we would be single tracking to Ballston due to a train broken down on the tracks ahead of us.

He then proceeded to speak to someone at Metro with the internal intercom on.

The conversation was mildly concerning, and was something to the effect that he had a code [alphanumeric] problem, couldn't see the other train on the tracks but would wait for a signal to go forward.

Yeah, just what you want to hear.

It took us what seems like forever to get to Ballston, and when we finally did, we really started to move, which was fantastic ... until we hit Virginia Square where the operator couldn't get the doors closed again. He tried closing them for five minutes, but finally announced that the train was out of service. The platform was packed already due to the delays, and now our train which was packed like sardines was offloaded onto an already packed platform.

I was one of the last people off the train, and there was no room for me to get off. We were packed right to the edge of the platform, and I had mild concerns I would fall if someone so much as sneezed.

The platform was so packed that people who were trying to get to the escalators couldn't get through. They yelled to be let through and everyone else yelled that they were stuck and couldn't move. It was chaos.

While we waited on the platform Metro announced they were running "especially late" due to the two train malfunctions. Shortly thereafter, I received an email notification from Metro about the disruption between Dunn Loring and Ballston ... which we had cleared 20 minutes prior.

The train sat on the tracks for another 10 minutes as workers inside the train tried to get the doors closed. After 7 minutes, according to the notification board, another train came, this one packed to the brim as well due to the earlier delays.

I normally wait for several trains to pass when it's crowded, but I was carried on to the train by people pushing behind me.

We held for another 5 minutes as the train struggled to get the doors closed due to the sheer volume of passengers. At each subsequent stop we encountered the same problem.

I normally give myself 60 to 75 minutes to make what is, according to Metro's online trip planner, a 45 minute commute. Today, it took nearly TWO HOURS. There was never any email notification of the further delays or that Metro was running "especially late." So, I missed my conference call and had to stay late to make up the time I missed.

Thanks Metro! It's totally worth the $10.80.

Other items:
SmarTrip cards available at Safeway (WMATA)
How Metro track circuits are supposed to work (WAMU)

Comments (39)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
That's really too bad. It's amazing how a problem with one train can cause that kind of back-up. To the author - when that happens to me, I get out of the station and get on the 38B, dubbed "The Orange Line with a View" to Rosslyn where I can get on an empty blue line train and make it to work with a relatively minor delay. Sorry it happened to you, man.
5 replies · active less than 1 minute ago
Corresponding Toads's avatar

Corresponding Toads · 750 weeks ago

lol @ The Orange Line with a View. Matt G you are the only person I've seen on here with some constructive ideas on how to fix Metro

your technique allows riders to skip the broken part of the rail and to ride a less crowded line. UR A JEANius

but I have a lot of friends who ar ejust TERRIFIED of metro buses, so this advice isn't good for them (don't worry they were'nt hit by any metro buses, they just have this thing like that kid in Angels in the Outfield where he's afraid to ride in cars 'cuz his family used to sleep in a car before he made it to the foster home and was saved by christopher walkin or was it christopher llyod? anyways catch you later)
How do you get off the platform?
Slow and steady wins the race. Just politely ask people with those two great words "Excuse Me" (no, that's not my bag announcement lady) - and you'll eventually get out OK. The transit apps on Android and iPhones incorporated with NextBus are a good way to find out where to go next. It's always a good idea to plan alternate routes to work using transit, just like when you are driving on the highway and you encounter an accident or hear it on WTOP. Roosevelt bridge blocked? No problem - diverting to Key Bridge...etc.

Perhaps it may cost you the extra $1 bus transfer, but it's worth it to have an escape plan when rail might go awry with unforeseen problems. I actually told the 38B, 2C, or C14 driver a few times when I've had to use those modes that the rail system was having problems - and they always let me ride for free, so I don't have to get charged more for a metro problem.
Unfortunately, some of us have no alternative routes to work. No car and bus routes that just don't leave us anywhere near the end desired nor with times that even work (assuming the bus is on time - funny thought!). Love the idea of changing trains but this orange line rider cannot take it via the blue. I need to get to Ballston and the blue doesn't head that way.
Thanks. This is good info. I was recently stranded at Virginia Square, and since everyone was offloaded, the Metro bus outside the station filled up very quickly, and I just grabbed a taxi as I was late for a meeting. I have, however, jotted down the above bus routes for future reference...
Ever and Anon's avatar

Ever and Anon · 750 weeks ago

"There was never any email notification..."

Has anyone else also noticed that the morning news stations always state "no Metro delays." There is always a delay when I get to the station, all of 2 minutes from my home having just seen that news "update."
4 replies · active less than 1 minute ago
Corresponding Toads's avatar

Corresponding Toads · 750 weeks ago

hello,

2 minutes may not sound like a long time, but there are actually 120 seconds in every 2 minutes. plenty of time for things to go wrong and by go wrong I mean it's not metro's fault, things just go wrong so get over it okay?

CT
Ever and Anon's avatar

Ever and Anon · 750 weeks ago

Get over incorrect news reports? Or get over Metro not reporting honestly? (What's "new" in that?)

2 minutes is a long time when it comes to Metro. Guess you do not know how to count Metro-math... 2 minutes + 2 seconds = 2 hour delay. :D
VeggieTart's avatar

VeggieTart · 750 weeks ago

It's quite possible that their newsfeed is delayed, and by the time they get the information and report it, that info is no longer accurate. Maybe the newscasters should say, there is always a delay on Metro. Deal with it.
Yeah seriously. I still subscribe to the email notification when there's a delay. It used to work fine. Within the past few months or so, it seems to have stopped working. I get few notifications and when I do get them, it's usually for delays that were cleared up to 60 minutes beforehand. WTF Metro, you can't even maintain your system that tells people you suck?
4 replies · active less than 1 minute ago
Corresponding Toads's avatar

Corresponding Toads · 750 weeks ago

lol, if an e-mail told you to jump off a bridge, would you do it??
Lol-
Why pay for service. at all when you cant seem to get it right!
I am now a "slug" with others.
Come on stop beggin the Fed Govt for more money, toad!
Ever and Anon's avatar

Ever and Anon · 750 weeks ago

That makes no sense in this conversation.
Only Metro can screw up like this. Ok, a train goes down, usually not a big deal, even for metro, but all the other stuff. amazing. we need a third tunnel!
5 replies · active less than 1 minute ago
Corresponding Toads's avatar

Corresponding Toads · 750 weeks ago

imagine this scenario for a second:

you're sitting at your cubicle, and your computer starts to smoke, and then it explodes.

see, stuff like this happens and it's not metro's fault so why not just sit back relax and enjoy the delays
Unfortunately, most of these types of problems are caused by passengers, not Metro. It's not Metro's fault that people think "stand back, doors closing" means "hurry up and break the doors open". If people were a little more respectful and patient, the system would run smoother. But instead, everyone is in such a damn hurry that they end up breaking the train doors.
Metro need bouncers. Or bouncers with machetes.
Corresponding Toads's avatar

Corresponding Toads · 750 weeks ago

it's not like he didn't make it to work at ALL! he got there eventually!

metro is the greatest
Ha! The fare system is so fragile that we have to hold SmarTrip cards an extra few seconds for it to calculate regular fares. No way it could handle when there was a problem - the cards would explode.
However, see my reply above for an alternative to paying extra fares when using alternate modes of transportation when there is a problem.
I think people need to start a "Petition" on line.
When people are late leaving or getting off the train a partial refund goes on the

Smart trip Card! Start the Petition Un suck and I will sign too!
This loss in money will surely make Metro More Accountable.

No one will be accountable until you hit "Their Back Pocket"
Then Metro can take money out of manager's pockets too and on down the line.

Why do we get punished?
Punish those who are NOT doing what is required!
Ever and Anon's avatar

Ever and Anon · 750 weeks ago

Does that work using Metro math? Where's my calculator..... ;-D
I was on one of those broken down trains, after what was a longer than normal ride we made it out of East Falls Church but then came to a stop, waited for what felt like about 30 minutes (meanwhile a train or two had gone past us towards Ballston) and then we went backwards into the East Falls station to offload.

The writing was on the while so I hopped on the other side and head back home in Merrifield for an unplanned work from home day. And I bet metro still charged me for my time (I should've paid more attention when exiting), thanks Metro!
Hey! Next time the train doors don't close>
look to see if that train was a 1000 Series Train.
When those 1000 Series Trains get crushed
the car will bow causing the doors not to close!
This is because the car actually bows which cause the door problems.
FYI-

Metro wants more funding for more trains and so you will see it more and more.

Management's motto-------"Let's inconvenience the customers more so we can get more funding".

You will see shorter trains- to inconvenience the customers, you will find trains

breaking down and delays more and you will see more and more headlines

referencing this so your D politicians can squawk for more e$$$$ funding$$$$.

I told you so!
Write your Congress woman/ manfor a refund.
2 replies · active less than 1 minute ago
Ever and Anon's avatar

Ever and Anon · 750 weeks ago

I wrote. To every congressional rep in my state even the ones who do not have any serious input/chance of action. After 2.5 months I got replies from the Senators but none from the House. One sent my letter to Sarles who replied via postal mail. Nice letter, definitely personalized to match my letter's points but no real info included. (At least it was not a canned response. I give credit for that - to the secretary probably. ;) The other replied with all they were attempting to do to help. I applaud those efforts; shame it seems as if they have as much "power" to fix the system as do we readers here. A refund was not part of the result.
Congress has as much interest as you have power.
Hey! Next time the train doors don't close>
find out if it is an old 1000 Series and the car is "bowing" so the doors won't close.

The WAMU article on track circuits is not the only problems with the Metro signals.
GlenmontGirl's avatar

GlenmontGirl · 750 weeks ago

Sounds like Metro is turning into VRE...
I'm sure it took a long time to get to work, and I know that the orange line really did have major problems on Monday, but did anyone else have trouble believing this because of the exaggeration at the beginning? "As usual, there were only two turnstiles open going into Metro." Really? As usual? I get on the Metro in Vienna every single day (at various times of rush hour) and there are usually only two turnstiles going OUT. In fact, having read this yesterday, I counted them today, and there were 8 turnstiles going into the system. Maybe it happened Monday, but that's not "as usual."

While I don't doubt that it took the OP a long time to get to work, exaggeration does a serious disservice to us as riders. If Metro KNOWS that we're exaggerating/lying, why would they ever believe the complaints that people file? Even if everything else the OP said was true, Metro can easily point to the first line as reasons for dismissal of a complaint. It's not right, but we know Metro looks for the easy way out and that gives it to them. Accurately documenting Metro's failures is what gives credibility to criticisms, and we should all strive for that.
ironmanjt's avatar

ironmanjt · 749 weeks ago

Then this morning, it took over 18 minutes between trains at Virginia Square without a single announcement. Way to communicate metro!
Conference calls are totally lame. What are you so upset about?

Post a new comment

Comments by

 
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License.
Site Meter