Wednesday, December 21, 2011

Who's More Opaque?


What's the number for the Metro police again?

C'mon Metro.

Not even two hours after I signed off until the New Year, you go breaking, bad.

A few thoughts before I really (hopefully) sign off until 2012.

A contributor mentioned that when there's an airline accident, they're forced to release tapes of the "black box" conversations and other pertinent records.

So, I'm wondering when we're going to hear the tapes between Operations Control Center (OCC), Metro's "nerve center," and the damaged trains regarding yesterday's mess. Will we see the results of the inspections of the 5000-series cars, which have a history of derailing? Will we hear the results of the "internal investigation" about the evacuation procedures?

Again, communications seems to have been a big issue.
That's just an example. Many riders complained about being left in the smoky dark (smoke condition) for a long time with no word about what was going on or what to do. Radio problems?

Sadly, it's not bloody likely we'll ever hear those communications or have any other independent view on what happened. We'll just have to take Metro's word.

Besides, according to several Metro sources, the tapes from OCC have a way of disappearing when they make Metro look bad.

So onto something that should be easier to get from Metro, the infamous "what if there wasn't a Metro" """"study."""" Metro has only released an executive summary so far.

I've asked chief flack Dan Stessel for the full version of the $200,000 """"study"""" three times, and zilch.

Dan, like every other rider, I'm a 16-ccent investor in that, and I want to see it.
Me (12/14): Could I please have the full copy of the study recently in the news?
Dan (12/14): Checking on its status…
Me 12/15): How's the checking going?
Dan (12/15): The text of the full report is being finalized. It will be released, most likely next week.
Me (12/20 before all hell broke loose): status?
Dan:(UPDATE 12/21): Checked on it this afternoon. It is still being finalized.
So they release an executive report of a """"study"""" that isn't ready for public consumption? What's being finalized?

Hmmm.

And finally, the whole mystery riders boondoggle. $252,000 (possibly $679,000) of your money spent on what exactly? It's not like things just need to be tweaked, and all will be well.

Here's what Greg had to say about that:
I know that in light of today's (12/20) egregious incident, the item below isn't as lurid, but I'm furious that Metro is spending public money to get feedback from system users. Evidently the tens of thousands of customer complaints it gets aren't an adequate source of information on what needs improvement.

As a taxpayer, I believe that the mystery shopper reports should be made public. These are, after all, merely observations made by the system-using public, so I don't see how any sensitive information could get disseminated.

And if it WERE disseminated, well, too goddamned bad!
My prediction as to when we'll see the mystery rider reports: Never.

At this point, it's a toss up as to who's is more opaque, N. Korea or WMATA.

And on that cheery note, I (hopefully) bid you very happy holidays and Happy New Year!

See you in 2012.

Other items:
Examiner take
Post take
Fox take
NBC take
ABC take
WTOP take

Comments (37)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I jeard an interesting nonsequiter on WTOP this morning. In a report on the Tuesday incident in which Mr Sarles was quoted, it was also mentioned that Sarles specifically made the point that he rides the Metro every day.
I'm not usually a conspiracy theorist, but the comment was so out of the blue that it caught my attention. Can it mean anything? Your post today makes me think maybe they are laying the goundwork for the full burial of the Mystery Rider reports, since after all, if the Board members ride the system therefore they know what regular riders experience. Or is it some some bigger plot, involving pentagrams and Masons and Dan Brown novels....
So if Metro is North Korea...
Jackie Jeter is Kim Jong Il (not because she's in charge, but because she's as bat shit crazy as he was)
Dr. Gridlock and Dan Stessel would share the position of minister of Propoganda
Any others? This could be fun!
4 replies · active 691 weeks ago
Metro with nuclear weapons - now that's a whole new kind of nightmare!
Where are you going with this? Real time geopolitics or "Team America: World Police"?
Either way I guess. I mean, I can see Metro treating outside inspection agencies the way Kim Jong Il treated Hans Blix in Team America....
A telling thing in that video: people were trying to call the metro police and the response was 'they are not picking up'.

So is the metro police # supposed to be the equivalent of 911 while in metro or not?
1 reply · active 691 weeks ago
If you call 911 and tell them you're having an emergency with Metro, they will automatically transfer you to Metro Transit Police.

At least that has been my experience when I've called 911 in the past for an emergency relating to Metro.
Unsuck ruled this story from the moment it broke. First place I saw it online was here. Excellent updates.

Why doesn't Mr. unsuck work for WMATA?
3 replies · active 691 weeks ago
He'd be fired in 5 minutes.
Yeah, crazy right? Unsuck would get fired for being a realist about everything but a guy who punches an off duty cop gets his job back.

Welcome to Jackie Jeter World!
But if Jackie Jeter were doing her job, Unsuck would be fired in five minutes but then be reinstated with back pay.
Then fired, and reinstated. With back pay.
Then fired, and reinstated. WIth back pay.
(Repeat ad infinitum)
The brakes would have to start falling off the trains before I went to work at Metro...I mean....
WordWrestleStessel's avatar

WordWrestleStessel · 692 weeks ago

You asked for a status update and I am happy to take the opportunity to address your request. No spin, even though I think you are asking just to get attention. We need to add an extension to our contract to get the consultants we hired for the study to add "FINAL" to the footer of each page of the report. We think it will take 6 months tops, assuming we get the approval of the supervisor's supervisor in procurement, and it should not cost more than another 200K. That's just another $.16 from our riders-- a true value for those reassuring footer words!
Stan Dessel's avatar

Stan Dessel · 692 weeks ago

Dear Unsuck (if that really is your name),

Why are you constantly seeking attention?

Sincerely,

Stan
1 reply · active 691 weeks ago
i accidentally voted this down before i read the username. my mistake "stan"
Again, Mr. Unsuck, thanks for postponing your vacation for this one. I'm sure it sucks to feel like a public utility that can't take the day off, but hopefully Metro can survive the remainder of the "slow" holiday period (tell me again why trains were 8 minutes apart, causing overcrowding and door problems this morning...) without any more debacles.
1 reply · active 692 weeks ago
Please, Unsuck is fine. No need for formalities;)
Long time reader, first time commenter.

I moved from the DC area a couple of months ago and recently learned a co-worker will be moving to DC next month. I told them they NEED to visit this blog and follow you on twitter. The midwestern small town idea of big city DC subway is shattered when you actually have to use it to commute.

I visit this site faithfully. Keep doing what you're doing!
Small point, but in the case of an airline accident, they don't *have* to release the cockpit voice and data recorder tapes. They're included in the print NTSB report which is public, and so they usually release the voice recording as well, but they don't have to. In fact, pilots' unions are fighting to keep those private. (And there's a big going-on in France where the tapes of Air France Flight 447 were released, when the investigation is still ongoing)
3 replies · active 691 weeks ago
Point taken. I guess for the most part, they feel compelled to most of the time, for some reason. Common decency perhaps?

Thanks for the clarification.
No problem. There are definitely pulls in both directions - the need to figure out what happened to prevent it in the future vs. what is often a recording of people dying. Some of those tapes are just bone chilling.
hrh king friday 13's avatar

hrh king friday 13 · 691 weeks ago

Everyone needs to go to WaPo's website and vote for Unsuck: http://www.washingtonpost.com/dctweeps

I think you have to complete the entire survey in order to have your vote recorded, but it still requires less time than taking the Metro.
4 replies · active 691 weeks ago
UnSuck Fan's avatar

UnSuck Fan · 691 weeks ago

Seriously? I just voted for UnSuck and then closed out. Wasn't interested in anything else.
hrh king friday 13's avatar

hrh king friday 13 · 691 weeks ago

I'm no expert on how it works, but the "submit your vote" button didn't appear until the end of the survey. Hopefully that's not the case and they record it as soon as you select UnSuck.
UnSuck Fan's avatar

UnSuck Fan · 691 weeks ago

UGH! I hate to say this and I know I'm going to sound like an ignorant boob, but I just went back to try to continue the survey. I've never even HEARD of anyone else; even in the poll that UnSuck is listed in. I recognize GGW because he's been mentioned a time or two here, but that's it. I think as close as I've ever got to reading anything he's posted was how he thinks that UnSuck and FIXWMATA should work with WMATA to in order to make things better (or something like that). Actually, time was short so I only read people's comments.

I tried to go on and look at the next survey question, but I have no idea who the heck these people are! Any names I just might recognize, I recognize because I've seen them in either or both of UnSuck's Twitter columns (i.e. Wardrobe Oxygen, Coolmcjazz, hollabackdc).

I hope everyone else benefits from these other people, but for me I guess I'll remain an ignorant boob.
russell.j.coller.jr's avatar

russell.j.coller.jr · 691 weeks ago

harsh.
I'm with Kim.
Radner Allan Poe's avatar

Radner Allan Poe · 691 weeks ago

Once upon a commute dreary, while I rode, weak and weary,
Reading many a long and boring columns of financial lore,
While I held on, nearly nauseous, suddenly there was a ruckus,
As the train bumped and squealed, sparks flew past the door,
" 'Tis some jumper," I muttered, "delaying the commute –
Only this and nothing more."

Ah, distinctly smoke was flowing, in the tunnel barely glowing,
Each wheel screamed, as we halted, all falling to the floor.
Eagerly I wished for information, vainly tweeting consternation,
With only silence from the speaker, the outlook becomes bleaker,
Time passes as we stand, staring at the floor, waiting for an open door,
Swearing to ride Metro nevermore.

Deep into the darkness peering, long we stood there wondering, fearing,
But the silence goes unbroken, and the darkness gave no token;
All the intercoms just seemed broken, while the fumes hard to ignore,
We finally get online, connect with Unsuck just in time
To learn that we are fucked, only to be stuck
In this hell for evermore.
5 replies · active 691 weeks ago
I nominate Mr. Poe for Metro Poet Laureate (which comes with a $200k annual salary and a union pension, of course)
russell.j.coller.jr's avatar

russell.j.coller.jr · 691 weeks ago

...there once rode a girl in from Huntington... [ ...soda dribbling out of my nose, seriously.]
russell.j.coller.jr's avatar

russell.j.coller.jr · 691 weeks ago

...there once rode a girl in from Huntington... ...who prayed very hard for a bit of fun... ...when she spied a big guy near Braddock... ...at work she thought only of his...... well you get the picture.
Would be great to see more of this kind of thing on top.

Thanks for sharing.
Anti-TB Guy's avatar

Anti-TB Guy · 691 weeks ago

“I want to thank the D.C. Fire Department for its leadership and recognize the outstanding job they did, both on incident command and on the safe evacuation of our passengers,” General Manager and Chief Executive Officer Richard Sarles said.

Metro update on Tuesday's Orange/Blue Line incident http://wmata.com/about_metro/news/PressReleaseDet...

Jeez, if I were the General Manager, I would have opened with an APOLOGY to all the frightened and inconvenienced passengers!

These guys aren't the masters of PR they think they are.
Have you ever tried an official FOIA request? Then they have to at least tell you why they won't release the information.
1 reply · active 691 weeks ago
I'm sure they'd go with their routine "It's too much of an administrative burden to compile the information" response.

Post a new comment

Comments by

 
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License.
Site Meter