Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Where are the Police?



Friday before last, I was heading home from Federal Center SW around 6:30 p.m. The station was pretty quiet, but I walked up toward the front of the platform where I usually get on the first car. There was a man with a cast on his leg and a cane waiting there as well.

As the train pulled in, I let him go on first. It was obvious that he was having a hard time and was in pain.

I took a left inside the first set of doors and sat down on one of the back-facing seats next to the operator's cabin in the little walled off area, and zoned out.

A few seconds later, I could tell something was brewing in front of me. I turned off the music only to hear a fairly normal looking middle aged woman in the first row of seats facing me hurling incredibly obscene abuse at the man with the cane.

The seats on the other side of the aisle were occupied, and he needed the leg room for his bad leg, so he was asking the woman to move her bag from one of the seats so that he could sit. She was refusing despite he pleas.

As the train pulled out of Federal Center, he was still standing. It was obvious he was exasperated and getting very angry that the woman would not move her bag.

She continued to insult him in every way possible, even going so far as to say he was faking his injury and calling him a sick pervert.

Finally, as the train sat for about five minutes in the tunnel on the way to L'Enfant, the two women on the other side of the aisle realized what was going on and moved.

The man with the cane hobbled over and with a very relieved look on his face, plopped down. I thought it was the end of the story.

But the abusive woman continued to insult him--really mean stuff about his looks, how he was dirty and a liar.

Politely at first, he told her to be quiet. She continued to harass him. He raised his voice and asked her to please stop. She continued and even took out a baby wipe to disinfect her bag "because he'd touched it."

Finally, he said "if you say one more thing, you're going to be sorry." You could tell he was about to boil over.

She called him a liar and continued to clean her bag and berate him.

He then stood up, yelled at her to shut, and drew his can up over his head like someone might do with an axe and took two steps toward her.

For a second, I thought he was going to bash her head in. It was a very tense moment.

I braced myself for the worst, but instead, he slammed the cane down hard on the bag she wouldn't move and told her that she was a horrible person.

She continued to lambast him as he hobbled off.

Mind you, it had been about 10 minutes since we'd left Federal Center, and we were not yet in L'Enfant. She then began to start in with me. Then she said something about her shoe size, which is finally when it dawned on me that she was very mentally ill.

When the train pulled into L'Enfant, I stepped out, and told the operator that he should call transit police. He said he'd seen what had happened and had called them.

I was relieved.

At Smithsonian, no cops. At Federal Triangle, no cops, At Metro Center, no cops. At McPherson Square, no cops. At Farragut West, no cops. At Foggy Bottom, no cops. At Rosslyn, no cops. At Court House, no cops. At Clarendon, no cops.

Finally, at Virginia Square, the woman who'd insulted pretty much everyone in the car the whole way, got off.

When we got to East Falls Church, where I get off, I asked the operator what had happened. He said he'd called the cops and shrugged his shoulders.

After I realized how ill the woman was, it was clear she did not present a physical threat to other riders, but she certainly was putting herself in a lot of danger as her illness was not readily apparent.

For a moment there, I thought she was going to get beaten up or worse, and I think it was only a matter of time until someone else took real offense at her insults.

I wonder if the operator even called the police, and if he did, I wonder why the cops didn't at least come to assess the situation.

Other items:
DC looking at private firms to run buses, streetcars (Examiner)
McDonnell presses Loudon to OK Dulles rail (Examiner)

Comments (61)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
There have been many stories of people with mobility issues not being able to find a seat. It's something people should be aware of when they get on the metro.

My one question for the writer of this article, who was sitting, did you offer your seat to him?

You may have a good reason why you did not, but you do not mention it in the article.
3 replies · active 665 weeks ago
He wanted the leg room the first row of seats offer so that he could have his leg straight. In the seats I was in, there is a wall immediately in front of them.
I think Jim is asking why the writer didn't get up and offer the man his seat.
I was thinking the same thing the other day on the Red Line as a woman took out a sandwich and drink and calmly ate and drank. I was angry but who could I tell?
2 replies · active 665 weeks ago
If you had said something you may have gotten slapped. I've seen it before. Last year a man mentioned to a woman he was sitting next to that drinking was not allowed on the metro. She continued and he mentioned it again. He got slapped. He then called the operator and who called the police. Three stops later (Rosslyn) an announcement told him to get off the train to talk to police. The woman got off at that stop as well, I think it was her stop. I don't know if she got stopped by the police.
It probably would not have mattered if a MTPD officer had been there. I had the same thing happen on a Red Line train towards Glenmont around 10PM a couple months ago. Guy eating a full chicken dinner across the isle. Metro Transit cop just happened to walk down the car and I drew his attention to the matter. He warned the guy to put it away and then walked away. Of course, the guy immediately started eating again and threw a few choice words my direction.
The thing that strikes me most about this article is - none of the other not-mentally-ill riders would get off their fat asses so a guy with a cane and broken leg could sit down?

Really?
3 replies · active 665 weeks ago
There were plenty of seats. He needed to sit in that row because he had a cast and needed the leg room.
Oh, fair enough. I reed gud.
Ever n Anon's avatar

Ever n Anon · 665 weeks ago

Wanna post that a third time, Unsuck? ;)

I see cops at one of my stations all the time standing and talking to each other. They never look at anyone walking by though.

I'd not assume the woman was the one in danger. The description of her actions tells me that she, too, could have easily become violent on anyone around her.
Every time I'm on Metro and hear the announcement from the head of Metro security about "if you need immediate assistance" I mentally finish it with "you're on your own."
1 reply · active 664 weeks ago
jenster8dc's avatar

jenster8dc · 664 weeks ago

Heh -- I finish it out loud with "you're f*cked."
OL Rider's avatar

OL Rider · 665 weeks ago

"At Smithsonian, no cops. At Federal Triangle, no cops, At Metro Center, no cops. At McPherson Square, no cops. At Farragut West, no cops. At Foggy Bottom, no cops. At Rosslyn, no cops. At Court House, no cops. At Clarendon, no cops."

Given that there is a finite # of Metro police, it is not surprising that these locations would be lacking police as they tend to be the most safe. That being said, two points: (1) Metro Center (like Gallery Place and L'Enfant) should always have police. (2) Even within the safe stretches such as Rosslyn to Ballston, there should be one within 3-4 stops.
1 reply · active 665 weeks ago
Yeah, I see them along the Green Line all the time, but not much on the Red Line. Pretty safe to say that yeahhhh...most of those Green Line stations need cops at them all the time.
I wouldn't expect to see a metro cop at Lenfant Plaza. While there should ALWAYS be police stationed at Lenfant, you almost never see them there. The Metro Police are usually putting in their time at stations like Vienna, where nothing will happen.
1 reply · active 665 weeks ago
Isn't L'Enfant where that huge fight took place a couple of years ago?
FreeMarketFan's avatar

FreeMarketFan · 665 weeks ago

When you only have seconds METRO police is only several stops away (if you're lucky)
I always see Metro Police congregated into a gaggle on the upper level of L'Enfant - rarely on the lower level, where most of the sketchiness is, IMHO.
I think I've seen this rider before. It was a woman, 32 years old, who was continually yelling because someone asked her to turn down her phone that she was playing music on without headphones. She was yelling how it was her birthday (it was actually my birthday that day, that's how I know her age), and she was yelling some incredibly vile things to an elderly woman. I turned up my ipod and turned away, the people closest to her started asking her to lower her voice and her music and she started yelling at them, the people next to the elderly woman called the police and at Falls Church the police came and she bolted as soon as she saw them. It never occurred to me that she was mentally ill, but only that if I got involved I'd be facing assault charges. This time, too, it was the first car and she was taking up the entire front seat with her bag and her feet.
4 replies · active 664 weeks ago
You know, just because you share a birthday doesn't mean you're the same age.
You know, just because my comment was long doesn't mean I included every last detail. She was yelling which birthday she was 'celebrating'.
Don't blame me - you're the one who said you knew her age because it was your birthday.
Don't blame me, I just stayed at a Holiday Inn Express.
If you want a police officer, get to Tenleytown: There is very often a couple of them talking to the station "manager" in the evening... They seem to be good buddies and hang around together there...
The Train Operator doesn't call the cops directly, but radios to OCC to request Transit. Then, Central Control then takes its sweet time to do *anything.* Transit gets the blame like a waitress who has to serve slop from a greasy spoon's kitchen.
2 replies · active 664 weeks ago
And even better, after relaying the call to MTPD, OCC won't hold the trains so the cops can intercept them!! It's like tring to catch a slippery snake! They'll stop a train in the middle of rush hour at a busy station for a sick passenger, but have a fight on a train, or even a report of someone that's armed, and good luck! They don't want to stop the train anf "throw" the train schedule off.

It makes sense to hold a train most times for sick people--how else is the ambulance going to catch up to the train to administer aid. Yet, for criminal situations aboard the train, just keep 'er movin' along! Makes sense---in a "Metro" sort of way!
But in the end, transit officers are blamed. The train probably got well into VA before the call was even relayed to dispatchers, and then they most likely would not hold it for an officer.
Funny, I had both these problems yesterday.

I'm standing on a crowded train, right in front of two interns sitting in the accessible seating--cane in my hand. Excuse me--and they ignored me so I waved in their faces so they would look at me. "If you don't have a disability, would you mind letting me sit down, please?" The looks on their faces was priceless. They were not happy but did get up.

Then last night at Gallery Place, the train op wouldn't open the doors because there was a thief trying to get off the train. He was running from car to car via the emergency doors. I called the police and had the pleasure of hanging up on a very rude and condescending woman who did not want a description nor did she care that we couldn't get away from a panicking criminal since the doors were closed.

If the OP's train op spoke to the same dispatcher I did, I bet that she is the reason the police did not show up.

Today is my telework day and I am going to enjoy every second of it.
3 replies · active 664 weeks ago
I LOVE that the operator locked the thief on the train! Only thing that would have been better is if a mob on the train held him down and tore pieces off of him like a band of zombies. That headline would discourage robbery for sure.
It was a bit surreal--I was the only one who realized what was happening. It was all tourists and me.

I was in the 8th car and ran to the end of the car and realized he couldn't jump out the last emergency exit cause he would land on the tracks.

So he turned around, ran back and went out the emergency exit he came from and jumped to the platform between the two cars.

Would have made a great video!
This is truly a no win situation though. Usually everyone gets all upset because the train operator doesn't lock the criminal on the train for the police to respond to. Now people are getting upset because the train operator DID lock the criminal on the train for the police to respond to.
I had a problem in Ballston and called MTPD once ... the problem was it took forever as he didn't have a car, rather was riding the rails too. And we all know how slow the trains are in the evening, plus he was using his personal cell phone to talk with me. Good thing my situation was not an emergency emergency.
Frequent red liner's avatar

Frequent red liner · 665 weeks ago

Sometimes in the afternoon I get off at metro center. There I have seen anywhere between two and five cops standing on the platform in the direction of silver spring/glenmont. All other times I get off at gallery place, where I see no cops. I'm not sure about their presence on the orange/blue platform at metro center, but the obvious lack of presence at key stations such as gallery place and l'enfany plaza is a serious issue that I wish we're addressed better. I agree with the previous poster that there should always be one within a few stops, more realistic than a cop at every single station.
There should be a police presence at EVERY station in the Metro system. Even if they are just sitting out on the street in an air conditioned car, they need to be available now, not at some point long after a train has moved on down the line and carried the threat/issue/danger with it.
4 replies · active 664 weeks ago
unfortunately, if they are sitting in their air conditioned car, it will probably take a couple of minutes to get to the train having the issue. in the example above, the train kept moving, so they would have to be in the stations. also, if they see someone run out of the station and then get the call, it may be too late.

they are not being paid to sit in air conditioned cars. they are being paid to protect those of us riding metro.
You're not suggesting that Metro employees should do the job they're paid to do, are you?
Sometimes, my friend, part of their job IS sitting in an air conditioned car. Ever think they are there for a reason? Don't assume you know the reason for their actions...
Wow...and you think fares are high now. You're talking about going from about 20-25 patrolling the ENTIRE system per shift, to about 68 per shift.

Pricey, pricey.....
This is scary indeed. Mentally ill people of this magnitude need help before they get themselves hurt, or hurt others. The police ignoring this are BEYOND negligent. Does anyone recall the mentally ill person in NY who pushed someone into the tracks just as a train was pulling in, or the other mentally ill person who smashed an innocent woman in the head with a brick? This is an extremely serious matter. That woman should have been taken in by the police and had a psych evaluation to determine if she was a danger to society or herself. The fact that metro police ignored this speaks volumes to how dangerous metro has become. I cannot ride the metro system anymore, because of the ever increasing threat to my safety.
9 replies · active 663 weeks ago
And speaking of handicaps and crutches, a few things come to mind. When I had had knee surgery, a bone graft in my knee, I was not allowed to bend my leg and had to keep it straight in the brace. When I rode metro at the time, I needed the seats with a lot of leg room, and where my leg would not get knocked by some feckless self-centered turd. When I got on the train and there were no seats, nobody ... NOBODY offered me a seat. People locked eyes with me, and yet did NOTHING. I stood on one foot, in pain, trying to use my crutches and hold onto the bars as the train jerked. I will never forget that. Ever. I was so exhausted from the pain and the drugs and what not, and had no fight left in me whatsoever to ask anyone to do the right thing and let me sit. Most people are so self-absorbed and never think of anyone else. I guess they figure if you still have one working leg, then you should still be able to stand!
The only thing I'll say is some people with handicaps, or temporary problems like yours, etc, will get *very* touchy about offers of assistance. "I'm not an invalid thank you very much!" kind of things.

But yes, definitely by the time you're making eye contact with them, they should figure out you're not one of those.
I agree! There is a blind woman that gets off at Dupont frequently. One time she was having issues finding the only up escalator (Oh that NEVER changes at Dupont!) and I asked if she need assistance. She about tore my head off and evacuated down my neck.
Similar problem's avatar

Similar problem · 665 weeks ago

I had the same issue after knee surgery, except that I'd occasionally get offered seats that I couldn't actually sit in, due to the need to keep my leg straight.
Someone really short's avatar

Someone really short · 664 weeks ago

I've witnessed this. The "Designated Seating for Persons with Disabilities" are no help because a straightened leg just sticks out into the isles, and is prone to more injury. Trying to find seating at either end of the car isn't the easiest thing to do when you only have full use of one leg.
On a side note as well, I know of two people, one a man and the other a woman, in the Dupont area that walk around on crutches all the time and ask people for money. They do look really dirty and homeless, but sometimes I have to wonder if they are scammers. It's like they crutch around specifically to gain more sympathy, and use that to get money from people. Whenever I see them crutching down the sidewalk, I always go to the other side to avoid them.
The cops weren't the ones to not respond -- it was the Office of Central Control who didn't getting in touch with MTPD dispatch. The train operators don't call MTPD, they radio in to OCC. OCC does NOTHING: think of air traffic controller who drink a lot of coffee and run reports, who don't even know how to key a mike or use any of their equipment.
I usually feel very safe when riding the metro, but I have lived in a lot of countries. I'll tell you. Shenzhen makes the bad parts of DC look like Clarendon, and those are the good parts of Shenzhen where atleast you might get robbed, but in the wrong part of town you'll get your organs removed. Anyway I mostly stay within the NOVA area, but I go into DC often, and I never have any problems. Though one time there was a fight on the train. The Metro police were quick to respond and kick their asses off the train.
there are cops at l'enfant most of the time. for my work, i take the metro usually three stops from l'enfant back up the hill to eastern market, usually walking down to the museums with kiddos.

i see the transit cops yakking it up above ground or sometimes in the station talking to the 'workers' in the kiosks at the 7th street/MD ave entrance. i take that train at all times in the day and evening so i don't see why if the cops were called they couldn't meet that train on the blue/orange platform in time to help out these folks.
1 reply · active 664 weeks ago
That's how it's supposed to work, but as I posted above, the folks in rail operations don't want to hold the train so it can be checked. The police are trying to catch a constantly moving target.
Back when I first started riding 20+ years ago there was a guy who used to scream at everyone else on the train that would get on every day. It was very uncomfortable as he was obviously mentally disturbed.

Yesterday AM there was a VERY aggressive panhandler at Rosslyn. SInce we had to wait forever for a train it was a long time listening to him yell that he needed 40 cents. Several people gave him money but he just kept going. Then of course ended up getting on the same train car as I did and continued yelling for 40 cents. I realize the cops can't be everywhere but the station managers out to be able to hear what's going on. Or they should at least be able to tell that there is a lot of yelling going on and investigate to see what's happening. I didn't feel threatened, but it made for a very uncomfortable situation. I suppose one os us should have used the intercom, but I'm not sure I would consider it to be an emergency exactly.
1 reply · active 664 weeks ago
I was at Rosslyn about a month or two ago and this guy was asking everyone for money while we waited the 20 minutes for the next train (I love Metro on the weekends). He was calling the women and smaller men derogatory things and in one case he switched to Spanish when the woman was Latino. He called her an F'ing Puta very loudly. She appeared to be very embarrassed. I wanted to punch the guy in the face for being such a coward. Needless to say, there was no around to stop this guy's panhandling.
rustytrowel's avatar

rustytrowel · 665 weeks ago

I experienced a similar situation on the Red Line. I was pregnant, 2 weeks before my due date, trying to get on at Metro Center. The train was crowded and people were pushing to get on and I bumped into a woman. Not hard, just tapped her. Before, I could say excuse me, she started yelling at me about how fat I was and called me every obscenity possible. I said I was sorry. She continued to tell me how fat I was for the next two stops. It was awful and I cried when I got off the train.
2 replies · active 664 weeks ago
ToughRyder's avatar

ToughRyder · 665 weeks ago

Please say you were crying because people like that are allowed out of their cages and not because they were mean to you.
When I was pregnant last summer, this woman yelled at everyone on the train because it was a hotcar and I was standing. She yelled at this little intern looking girl until she got up. Although it was rude, I was so grateful. I didn't like asking someone for their seat because as others have said in the past, we don't know what their incapabilities are.

Separate story. . . a couple of weeks ago, I was on the red line to Glenmont and the train was PACKED!! At NY Ave, someone sitting on the window side in the middle of the train decided to fight the pack to get out at the last minute. I had my gym bag with me and it literally touched this woman who was sitting down. She said she had a sore shoulder, but there was nothing in other than some papers and my pump and it was resting on my shoulder. This woman yelled at me. When it went up the hill to RI Ave, my bag touched her again and she threatened to hurt me. Now, she could have easily beaten the crap out of me so I apologized (know your battles), but all I thought was that this woman would seriously take an assault charge because my bag was TOUCHING her? While she is sitting and I am standing on a packed train?!!
Who sits and takes notes or "braces" himself as someone raises his cane to bash another's head in? I would have been on my feet and that cane would have been in my hand the moment he raised it - I don't care who was at fault. No cane-bashing on the train! That's just uncivilized!
2 replies · active 664 weeks ago
You're really going to get into the middle of a fight between a crazy person and someone with a weapon? Good luck with that.
Jaundice James's avatar

Jaundice James · 664 weeks ago

Yes, you city slobs, unliking my comment. (See, this is why everyone went to jail at the end of Seinfeld.) Yes, yes. By all means, freakin' DO something! Someday maybe you'll need assistance. You want a bunch of wide-eyed spectators watching as some fool bashes your head in? Be a human being, for crying out loud!
The OP should submit his itinerary to MTPD prior to his trip. So the MTPD can detail someone to follow the OP wherever he/she goes. OP ensure to mention what train car and what seat you will be seated in so MTPD can have an Officer stand at the precise location on the platform so that he can look in the window at you and your shadow Officer as your train pulls into each and every station you listed on your itinerary, to ensure that you, the OP are safe. Furthermore, I find it honorable that the OP exited at every station he listed in his tirade, checked both platforms, any and all mezzanines and any and all topside areas of the stations to ensure that for a fact no MTPD were present at ANY of the stations he/she listed. Kudos OP.

Post a new comment

Comments by

 
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License.
Site Meter