Tuesday, July 31, 2012

Pathological


This fishy brakes thing has gotten ridiculous.

Why can't Metro just level with us?

First, in an effort to refute an article here, Stessel said they hadn't use the brakes in years.

Then, unbelievably, he went with the Big Lie, saying the smell was "sewer gas."

Now, when the press comes knocking, Metro won't even respond.

Yesterday, the Examiner reported:
The problem is that Metro doesn't seem to know what is causing it -- or doesn't want to tell the public. Agency officials declined to answer repeated questions about the smell last week. In the past, the agency has blamed sewer gas and the trains' brake pads.
Remember the new transparency that was supposed to be ushered in by Sarles, Stessel, et al?

Now Metro can't even cop to a problem they already copped to (and apologized for) in 2006!

This regime is even more secretive and opaque than ones before it.

I asked one of my sources about the brakes.

"If it smells like rotten fish, that's the organic brake pads, period," said the source who is knowledgeable about the brake issue.

Another source at Metro calls any other story about the odor "BS," adding "they didn't use [the pads] for a period of time but started again. They never ran out of what they had to begin with."

Why Metro continues to obfuscate is really beyond me. My Metro sources don't think there's any potential health risk to the smell. It just really, really stinks.

The incompetence of the PR staff at Metro is mind blowing. Here's what appears to be a relatively simple issue to get past, but instead they've let it stew for almost a year, the whole while undermining whatever tiny bit of credibility they might have left.

It's really not that hard, Metro.

Interesting footnote: Apparently, when the brakes gets wet, they also smell like rotten fish, even if they're still in the box. A source tells me this happened once at Greenbelt, and and entire pallet had to be moved to a more aerated place because of the horrible smell.

Comments (30)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
And their Twitter folks have given up too ... they just don't respond to most questions/complaints anymore. Like BA, the new person has burnt out too. So over this joke of an agency with no oversight.
9 replies · active 660 weeks ago
And again, what do the gain by this? Baffling.
+1 million. Thx FixWMATA for the update. Explains why the high levels of sazz and being angry at customers continues.
I was told employees inject something into the cracks of the cracked tunnel walls and this causes the odor. However, perhaps the injections are to stop the whatever is leaking into the tunnel. Maybe an outside contractor needs to be mandated to test the sludge wayside causing the odor.

I know for a fact if you lie for the company and lie for the union you get promoted and or re-elected. When you have managers with drug problems and criminal records leading the way what do you expect from the top but lies and cover-ups.
Then why do outdoor stations with no tunnel walls often smell? Fort Totten and Franconia-Springfield have been reported as having the fish smell.
When they do respond, it is. "Please submit a complaint form" (that will go directly into the trash folder/recycle bin of a WMATA computer).
I think this is pretty spot on.

Lots of hype, no follow through.
Its not that they don't respond... they've just blocked everyone who is critical of Metro...
Well, Richard Sarles IS about as reclusive as Kim Jong Il was....
At least Metro is consistently good at trying to cover its ass...even when there's not really anything to cover for.

"Yeah it's the brake pads, no we won't order them again, but rather than throwing away money since they do succeed at stopping the trains we're going to use up our current inventory before getting new brake pads."

Then again this reminds me of the story from a week or two ago with the bus that went the wrong way for something like an hour and a half...apparently the driver thought that some BS about "safety first" was a better way to defuse the situation than just saying "Sorry, I messed up." Especially since the roads around here are SO straightforward and NONE of us has ever missed an exit on them before.
Ever get that not so fresh feeling?
http://jeangraesalterego.files.wordpress.com/2010...
M. Saeed al-Sahhaf's avatar

M. Saeed al-Sahhaf · 660 weeks ago

There is no odor. There are no swamp gasses and there are no brake pads. We have no problems, everything is perfect. People love WMATA. We open doors! Praise Sarles.
jenster8dc's avatar

jenster8dc · 660 weeks ago

Just one of the eighty billion things I do not understand about Metro. Why can't they be honest about what's causing the smell? If it's not toxic, what's the big whoop. Just tell us. Easy. Why can't they replace light bulbs in dark stations? Not a big fix. Probably doesn't require special techs. Why

I have a vision of people just wandering the hall of Metro HQ, just bumping into each other and not being able to find the bathroom or their desks.
2 replies · active 660 weeks ago
"Why can't they replace light bulbs in dark stations?" Aren't the only lit stations the outdoors ones when the sun is shining?

This is something I've wondered as well. Why are the stations so dark? After living abroad for years (S. Korea), when I came back to the the Metro, I honestly thought there was a power outage or something. What gives?
When you have to head over to a lit advertisement or map in order to read something.

I used to think they left some of them off to save electricity. Some were still being replaced so it was clearly on purpose that others were out. When the ones that were lit before started burning out and not being replaced I just decided they were being lazy.
"My Metro sources don't think there's any potential health risk to the smell." I am very interested to know if this is really the case. It would not surprise me at all if Metro ordered the brake pads knowing there were health risks associated with them. That's how much I think Metro does not give a crap about me or anyone else who rides the system.
horseydeucey's avatar

horseydeucey · 660 weeks ago

My concern is this: I don't trust WMATA.
I think it serves them well for us to believe the smell is caused by organic brakes.
Again, I don't trust WMATA.
The very fact that they are so dodgy about the source of the smell does not make me confident that the smell isn't cancer.
It smells like cancer to me, not fish.
UnSuck Fan's avatar

UnSuck Fan · 660 weeks ago

And you thought “Something is Rotten in Denmark” was bad.
2 replies · active 660 weeks ago
I just returned from Denmark. I never waited more than two minutes for a train even though they claim a maximum of fifteen minutes between them on weekends.
The new brake pads do smell fishy but this odor is always a nasty smell at the under ground stations in DC.
Smell, schmell, as long as METRO doesn't kill me or anyone else, I'm OK with it.
1 reply · active 660 weeks ago
So you know the smell is not something harmful how exactly?
I emailed csvc last week to ask why the 3 out of 5 of the escalators at Franconia-Springfield were out of service, yet the escalator/elevator webpage said that there were no service issues at the station. Their response was:

"Platform escalators are always reported by the station manager. Metro stands behind the integrity of its data. Safety is our number one priority."
Next they'll be blaming it on CHUDS.
What did the blind man say after boarding the smelly Metro car?

"Good morning, ladies!"
I am very concerned about the health effects of the smell which seems to be at an all time high at the Rosslyn station the past few days. If I could take a bus home to avoid being overcome by the stench I would. It makes me feel like I have acid in my stomach by the time I get on one of the poorly air-conditioned cars. I don't know how this cannot be taken seriously by metro. I would not be surprised if in years to come a report comes out that metro riders who were exposed to this smell on a regular basis have serious health issues. Drano smells bad, that's why you ventilate when you use it because it can pose as a serious health issue if you expose yourself to it by inhaling. How is this any different?
vienna gal's avatar

vienna gal · 658 weeks ago

I am very concerned about the health effects of the smell which seems to be at an all time high at the Rosslyn station the past few days. If I could take a bus home to avoid being overcome by the stench I would. It makes me feel like I have acid in my stomach by the time I get on one of the poorly air-conditioned cars. I don't know how this cannot be taken seriously by metro. I would not be surprised if in years to come a report comes out that metro riders who were exposed to this smell on a regular basis have serious health issues. Drano smells bad

Post a new comment

Comments by

 
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License.
Site Meter