Tuesday, July 26, 2011

Guest Blogger: FixWMATA, Tracker of Hot Cars





A couple more choice tweets from Metro: here and here

From FixWMATA (Twitter/website):

Here's the thing - I don't WANT to track WMATA "hot cars!" I'd rather these cars get fixed and WMATA have a plan in place to address them in a timely manner when reported.

I would LOVE for this problem to become history.

The problem is the hot cars are getting worse, and the communication from WMATA has mostly come to a full stop, despite an overly advertised "aggressive social media campaign" to keep riders informed.

When I started tracking hot cars this year, I sat down with Dan Stessel, Metro's chief spokesman, and had a very friendly chat about the problem and what he intended to do about it in his new role.

He said he would use my website to communicate the reported hot cars to maintenance each night so the problem would get addressed.

I loved this attitude and decided that, unlike last year, I would be on his side and try to have a spirit of cooperation this year.

Over the next few weeks, I would ask Dan for a list of cars that were "fixed" so I could note it in my database and give them proper credit for handling the situation.

I never once got that list!

Furthermore, I saw the problem with hot cars getting worse.

Did Dan give me lip-service?

I hope not.

But in any case, after I pursued the issue more aggressively with him, the communication stopped.

Other than the occasional message about using the intercom to report a hot car, the Metro Twitter account has stopped mentioning hot cars altogether, despite a torrent of reports from riders.

So what's happened?

Has Metro found they CAN'T fix the hot cars and decided that instead of admitting that, they will just go silent on the issue?

Did Dan get an unhealthy response from maintenance and can't report results to us, but doesn't want WMATA to look bad?

Does Dan have a personal beef with me and therefore is ignoring the issue I'm championing and thus putting his personal issues above "potential health issues" facing customers?

We may never know.

So, yes. I do have a salty, snarky, bitchy attitude right now.

This attitude comes out of frustration at the lack of a response from Metro after I put forth a good-faith effort to work with them to solve one of THEIR issues.

WE the riders continue to do the legwork in identifying hot cars, and I continue to provide the lists they need to fix the problem.

But it remains unfixed.

WE the riders continue to sweat every day on our commutes.

Where do we go from here?

Can WMATA do an about-face and address the issue?

Do I stop trying to champion the issue on behalf of frustrated commuters?

Do we continue to shout into the dark?

Will the media catch on to the frustration and get Dan's attention on the issue?

I will continue to hope for a day that we can all work together to make WMATA better, but right now these conditions don't exist.

I'm open to suggestions.

If you want to know the extent of the problem, here are hot cars by the numbers:

These are the HotCar record results for 2011 as of July 23, 2011. These records have been kept to the best of my ability since May 24, 2011.
  • Number of days on record: 61
  • Number of records: 673
  • Average records per day: 11
  • Number of records more than last year: 467
  • Number of individual Twitter users reporting: 374
  • Twitter user with the most reports: @seauxbrown with 10 records
  • Number of unique WMATA rail car numbers reported: 338
  • Total number of WMATA rail cars in fleet (per 2011 budget report): 1106
  • Percent of all WMATA rail cars reported as hot car: 31% (that means almost 1 in 3 WMATA rail cars have been reported)
  • Car reported most: car 5037, reported 11 times this year (on 6/21, 6/28, 7/8, 7/11, 7/18, 7/19, 7/21)
  • WMATA rail line with the most records: Red Line - 232 reports
  • WMATA car series with the most records: 5000-series (37% of all reports) - note: the 5000-series makes up only 17% of the total fleet)
  • Percentage of total 5000-series reported: 61% (113 unique car numbers reported out of 184 total 5000-series cars)
Other items:
Interesting take on Metro's eating/drinking law (Overcriminalized)
MetroAccess growth slows (Examiner)
Metro to will abandon @metroopensdoors, use @wmata instead, finally
Meet the voice of Metro (TBD)

Comments (39)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I haven't ridden Metro in weeks. Buses, sure, but those are generally not that bad unless you need to transfer to another bus (outside of rush hour one has to use Swiss precision in timing). And y'know what? I don't miss it at all.
1 reply · active 451 weeks ago
"Do we continue to shout into the dark?"

The answer is yes. They have made it abundantly clear that they don't care. They are not interested in the welfare of the riders. Unfortunately the loudest shout of all, the one that will get their attention, is when a customer actually dies on a hot car. They like to ignore that the system is used by people in poor health, elderly people, people with severe breathing issues, etc. I can assume that the work of riders to report which cars are hot cars is appreciated by those that can't survive the heat. Please keep it up.
4 replies · active less than 1 minute ago
Soylent Green Line's avatar

Soylent Green Line · 716 weeks ago

This is going to sound incredibly morbid, but please don't take it to mean that I'm insensitive. But how many people died in the Red Line accident? How has Metro improved since then? Trains still run past red lights with alarming frequency, don’t they?

If someone were to die due to a hot car, WMATA would probably just put out some toothless advisory asking at-risk individuals to not ride Metro when it's too hot instead of doing anything.

Not even death deters WMATA from their unwavering dedication to stoic ineptitude.
Sad but true.
Exaclty. Why does anyone think a death would deter these pathetic scumbags from screwing over the common man.

Can we please FIRE EVERYONE that works for this system?
Nobody wants to report a hot car for fear of it being taken out of service and then we are all crammed in to other crowded cars. Not to mention the delay. I was on a hot car on Thursday 7/21 and a Metro employee with vest on got off because it was so hot. I don't know if he reported it or not but if he isn't going to report it who will?
Soylent Green Line's avatar

Soylent Green Line · 716 weeks ago

"But in any case, after I pursued the issue more aggressively with him (Stessel), the communication stopped."

Based on Stessel's previous ill-fated attempts to ingratiate himself with this blog's readers, I'd say this reaction is about par for the course.

In fairness, maybe Mr. Stessel didn't realize exactly how bad WMATA has become. For all we know, this communications blackout could be due to the fact that he's in a padded room, chewing on his blankets and ruing the day he agreed to take this job with such an incompetent organization.
Thanks for this article, we need more like these on Unsuck, articles that clearly and concisely show via the numbers what metro is doing.

Question FixWMATA - have you considered making an escalator tracking service? I ask because we all know that curtain escalators have say a 25% uptime number - yet metro skates by with the 90% system wide number - oblivious to the fact that curtain passengers see the same escalators out repeatedly for years on end.
4 replies · active 716 weeks ago
Soylent Green Line's avatar

Soylent Green Line · 716 weeks ago

FixWMATA:

Do you have a link to access your records online? If I missed it in the article, my apologies. But if it's not publicly accessible, maybe posting it online somewhere (maybe even embedded onto this blog) would be a good way to raise awareness.

Apologies again if I'm just missing it.
Soylent Green Line's avatar

Soylent Green Line · 716 weeks ago

Touche...
Also - I'm extremely bugged to see advertising and news reports saying that the current metro issues will be solved with the new order of rail cars. They said the exact same thing before they released the current set of "new" cars...
1 reply · active 716 weeks ago
You have to wonder if the new cars are supposed to hop off the tracks and fix escalators/elevators. Or maybe they will do customer service instead?
MadAsHeck's avatar

MadAsHeck · 716 weeks ago

What about the heat in stations? I remember in previous years, I saw large portable fans set up on some platforms to move the air around. This year, when we're setting record hot temperatures, I haven't seen any fans.

Where are the fans? Cooling Sarles & Stessels' offices?
2 replies · active less than 1 minute ago
Credit where it's due and all-Foggy Bottom has had (some) air conditioning turned on or fixed this this year-the first I can remember since I started taking the Metro six years ago.

And believe me I noticed-in previous years, one could sweat just standing on the platform and it actually seemed hotter than the outside. In the recent heatwave, it was tolerable generally and I could actually feel cool air coming out of a couple emitters.
hrh king friday 13's avatar

hrh king friday 13 · 716 weeks ago

If you think employees of a major city's public transit system should maintain its AC systems so that men, women and children of all ages and races don't SUFFOCATE AND DIE, then clearly you believe in slavery.
FOIA the list.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
Last week, all the trains I took to and from work (vienna and farragut west) were hot cars. Someone always contact the train operator but his response is just to move to another car which is useless since the entire train is hot. This week is so far a little better. No a/c in the morning commute yesterday but limited on the afternoon commute. When you contact metro, they deny a/c is broken. The reason they give is that it's too hot and the a/c is unable to compensate. LMAO. I started driving again today. Sucks to be in traffic but at least my car has a/c.
8 replies · active less than 1 minute ago
The car I was in coming out of West Falls Church yesterday morning had no a/c-and this was the driver's car! I moved into the 2nd car a few cars down and it was cool.

This stuff is quality assurance and employee performance 101: the driver should check the operation of the a/c in ALL cars during hot weather (and the heat in cold weather)-before putting the train in service. Why doesn't this happen?
the operator does check the train consist. even if the operator reports a hot car in his consist, he is instructed to continue on with that train. it is not up to the operator to remove the train from service.
airlines are under FTA.. Metor is "I will do as I please" who is going to stop me...Not OSHA, FTA or even Congress is going to stop us. Riders are at Metro's mercy. Until ridrs--the public protest nothing will get better. You, the riders, are voters, let your offical know you had enough. Plan a protest and demand your elected offoicals to make changes... Riders, voters you are their boss. Let your voices be heard Make a change
Actually, if the operator was in these conditions, he can contact OSHA.
former employee's avatar

former employee · 716 weeks ago

Have you asked "Dan" how many trains are "defer" to make revenue. although they needed maintenance... It is supposed to be documented. It is Metro's priority to make "revenue: It would not be acceptalbe to ask FTA or airline to defer a plane Would you the public like to know what car/train was defer and would you ride it... Just a thought. A good thing trains are not according to FTA standards, you would be walking. there would not be a train available... This is the truth... Metro wings their shit...If onlyu you knew... I called all of the saftey people. Metro is thier own Entiy , we don't get involved
WMATA trains don't crash to the ground in a firey heap of rubble if the A/C doesn't work.

Hot car or no car, it's your choice.
Yesterday, an orange line heading towards New Carollton had THREE cars in a row that had no air conditioning... it was terrible.
Red line had 2 cars today that had no AC. As per usual.

FIRE EVERYONE in this pathetic unionized system.
Gotta love government-work. "Tracking" the hot cars using social media and Twitter is considering "action" by this make-work agency.
RedLineROFL's avatar

RedLineROFL · 715 weeks ago

Has anyone heard from @FixWMATA? No tweets or replies to #hotcar, and his site is "off the rails". I sure hope we didn't lose this valuable resource.

Post a new comment

Comments by

 
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License.
Site Meter