Thursday, January 19, 2012

Metro is Accessible?


Illustration

How hard is it to announce elevator outages in a timely and effective way? There are a lot of people who desperately need this information to travel safely in Metro.

Maybe a study about what if there were no elevators would be beneficial. Of course, it would have to cost at least $200,000 to be worthwhile. Maybe Metro should hire a staff to tweet, and Facebook about elevator outages.

I mean seriously, Metro can already be a pain for the able bodied, but when you hear stories like this, which are becoming all too common, you just have to shake your head.

From Denise, who has written before:
I am a Metro rider who is blind and reliant on a guide dog. The other morning, beginning at 8:50, I was stranded in Metro's Smithsonian station for 45 minutes. I was on the Blue and Orange platform in the direction of Largo and New Carrollton. The platform elevator was broken, as is often the case.

There was no announcement over the loudspeaker that the elevator was broken and no information of where a shuttle bus was being made available for those with special needs.

The station attendant refused to stop an escalator so the guide dog and I could walk up. (A moving escalator can break a guide dog's back feet, and some guide dog users prefer not to ride one.)

In the past at Smithsonian, an escalator has been stopped after rush hour, which, by this time, it was. That would have allowed me to exit the station.

In addition to refusing to help, the attendant actually walked away from me. She said that she sent for a "supervisor," but she did not know when, or even if, that person would arrive.

Fortunately, a sighted colleague showed up and helped.

We took the train to L'Enfant Plaza and finally Left Metro. I then walked seven blocks to work, which I would not have had to do had I exited at Smithsonian.

A commute that takes me usually under 30 minutes took over 90, with no assistance from a Metro bureaucracy that is becoming more and more disorganized and chaotic by the day.

There were two other colleagues who helped me that day. They said they wanted to write to you as well. We believe you do much more good than the Metro ADA Office, which appears to take no action on written complaints.
I did hear from Denise's co-worker:

From Becca:
As this is not the first time this has happened, I thought it was time to bring this to your attention.

I have a blind employee who navigates the treacherous streets of DC with her trusty seeing-eye dog. (Quite brave if you ask me!)

Sometimes, she can get to work with no problem, and other days it's quite an adventure.

The other day, like several other days in the past, the elevator [at her station] was broken, and since moving escalators are too dangerous, she has no choice but to be stuck on the platform until she can either flag someone to get a Metro employee or call someone and ask them to come and [turn the escalator off long enough for her to get out].

This particular morning, she was on that platform for 45 minutes before she could get someone to find a Metro employee.

She could have gotten out of the Metro station if they would just shut off the escalators for a minute while she and her dog walk out, but several times now, Metro employees have refused to shut them off (interesting since they are often off anyway so any claim about inconveniencing multiple customers couldn't apply here).

She has had no choice but to get back on the Metro and go to another station where she can take an elevator and then has to walk (across four lanes of rush hour traffic) or hail a cab (which also isn't an easy thing to do being blind with a big dog) to work.

Often, she has to call a co-worker to come help, which now means that two people aren't at their desks.

As an employee working in legislative affairs, she is counted on for handling urgent and high-level issues, so her inability to get to work for a reason that could be easily dealt with is completely unacceptable.

Metro needs to get some policies in place and make sure all of their employees know how to handle these types of situations.
Related (and here and here and here)

Other items:
Metro employees accused of stealing thousands (WaPo)
Dulles stop could be scrapped (Examiner)
Metro adding $7.1 million worth of cameras to train cars (Examiner)
Metro may install shields for bus drivers (WaPo)

Comments (52)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Calabria's avatar

Calabria · 687 weeks ago

This just makes me sad. And angry at Metro and people's lack of empathy and respect.
What is wrong with this notion? If they stopped the escalator they can't start it again? Why not? A handicapped person has to suffer because the escastairs aren't properly maintained so that they can be stopped and then restarted? Unacceptable.
DC Denizen's avatar

DC Denizen · 687 weeks ago

I agree- this does seem like a good option. The only thing I could think is that if they couldn't re-start the escalators and someone else came through that couldn't climb the stairs or for whom stairs are a challenge, then that next person would be screwed.

The best solution is to fix the freaking elevator.
russell.j.coller.jr's avatar

russell.j.coller.jr · 687 weeks ago

oh....SNAP!
Do they leave the escalators running all night? I have definitely seen escalators stopped one day and running the next day, so to say they can't restart them is false. Eventually, they will restart it.

We deal with broken escalators in every other station and as a rider I would rather be inconvenienced to allow this woman to exit rather than just due to incompetence and misspending.

I also want to point out that when elevators are out, it would be helpful for people to know that the escalators are out at those stations as well. Some people rely on moving stairs or the escalators and if they know both are out, may request other assistance.
I was going to suggest the same, perhaps usnig the emergency stop button on the escalator whenever something like this happens would get Metro's attention...

I visited NYC a few weekends ago, and it is amazing to me how much more ADA accessible their stations can be. (part of the reason for this is because the stations are much more shallow than WMATA stations.) But, nonetheless, station managers seemed to always be doing //something// at their stations, rather than just looking at the monitor of where the trains are, or yelling at passengers.

I am no escalator expert, but I am certain that pushing the emergency stop button is probably more of a hassle for a station manager than just restarting the escalator. I would try and find it every chance you get.
Sorry, but I've never had this experience with New York station managers. Sure they're helpful when you need them, but they always seem to be missing. I may be a member of the minority, but the station managers have always been helpful to me, even letting me through the gates when they know I've got a broken far card.

As for using the emergency stop button, I'm all for it so long as no one is on the escalator at the time.

There's a blind woman who gets off at Farragut North each morning around the same time as me. Its wonderful to see how everyday, people (regular citizens and Golden Triangle BID workers) go out of their way to help her from the station to the Circulator bus stop. I'm honestly shocked that it seems people did not do more for the original poster.
Sadly not even shocking anymore. Metro employees can be complete and utter ASSHOLES to their customers without fear of any repercussions. This is because WMATA doesn't want to be accused of being racist thanks to Jackie Jeter's race baiting union.
DC Denizen's avatar

DC Denizen · 687 weeks ago

If you use the emergency stop, it might be good to give anyone on the escalators a heads up that you're going to push the button so no one takes a tumble.
2 replies · active 687 weeks ago
Good point!
and likely the elevator must be checked out by maintenance crew to start it up again....just the rules.
Soylent Green Line's avatar

Soylent Green Line · 687 weeks ago

This is the kind of story that needs to be pushed to other media sources. Hopefully, Unsuck, you can help make that happen - and other readers can do so as well if they know how.

Metro can and will ignore heart-wrenching stories like this when they're posted to this blog. But they can't help but respond if they're included elsewhere and exposed to a larger audience.

OP: I would encourage you and your colleagues to name and shame the station manager if this happens again. The anonymous complaints aren't going to get anything done because they're too easy to ignore.

At the least get a name!

SGL
1 reply · active 687 weeks ago
Good luck with getting Dr. Gridschlock to do anything on it...
Just to make sure I understand Denise's story, is it that the walk from L'Enfant to her office is too difficult/dangerous to make without the assistance from a sighted colleague? Otherwise (and this is not to absolve Metro and the employee from their ridiculous disregard of passenger needs), I'm not sure I understand why she had to wait the 45 minutes at Smithsonian.
2 replies · active 687 weeks ago
My guess is that she didn't know that it would end up taking 45 minutes to resolve the issue. Had Metro assisted her promptly in the first place, she could have exited at Smithsonian and had a short walk to her office, on a route that is likely very familiar to her and her guide dog. Had she known that Metro would refuse to help for so long, my guess is that she would have sought help from her co-workers earlier.
Sighted Colleague's avatar

Sighted Colleague · 687 weeks ago

I'm the sighted colleague who walked with her from L'Enfant Plaza back to our workplace. We waited a good 20 minutes for the supervisor to show up, but he/she didn't. The station attendant, whose name tag read "Smith", didn't say how long it would take, time was a-wasting, so it was easier to go to L'Enfant and walk back.

We talked briefly about catching a cab from L'Enfant, but most cab drivers don't like to take the dog and I'm an African-American man...not a good cab-catching situation in this city. We figured it would be faster to walk back to our workplace, than to spend the time catching one.

Dealing with the station attendant, the ride to L'Enfant and the walk back took 40 - 45 minutes out of my work day. I'm a Webmaster for a large part of our workplace's website and am very busy with a lot of updates, uploads, general repairs, new content creation, etc. I need all the time I can get , so Attendant Smith's refusal to help Denise cut into my productivity as well as Denise's.

Denise has excellent mobility skills, but there are times when it's more efficient for her to walk with a sighted colleague. Since I was already in the system with her, LP was the best solution.
Screw the station manager, I would have cleared the escalator and hit the emergency stop button as mentioned before. God forbid a WMATA employee do their job!
Similar problems this morning in Bethesda. No street elevator and no escalators running up the 10 stories to the street. I am only slightly handicapped in that I cannot climb the escalator in 25 degree cold without landing in the ER with an asthma attack. There was also a man with a cane and several elderly people for whom the climb was out of the question. I called Metro and spoke to two different women. They first asked me to get instructions from the station manager. When I told them that he was nowhere to be found, I was told to take the train back to the next station and request a shuttle bus from there. (in other words Metro Access, which could take hours) I explained that since this was a station-wide closure, it was Metro's normal procedure to announce which station they would run a shuttle from, and to centrally dispatch that shuttle. The second lady just stopped talking for approx two minutes and then asked if there was anything else she could help me with. End call. The station manager then appeared from the engineer room where he had been for the last 15 minutes or more. He advised the same thing--go to another station and take a bus. I took some video of the broken equipment, and then took the train back to Medical Center.
3 replies · active 687 weeks ago
I've had the same issue - due to asthma, I can't walk up the long escalator at Dupont (my home station) in certain weather conditions. Normally I walk to work, so I only take Metro on days when weather conditions are especially likely to exacerbate my asthma. If the escalator and elevator are both broken, usually I pay to go back in and cross over to the south exit, even though this nearly doubles the length of my walk home in the bad asthma conditions. But now that the south exit will be closed for 9 months, I'm pretty apprehensive about what might happen if the elevator and escalator break down on the north exit. I guess I'll have to figure out the bus schedule.
You could exit at Woodley Park and jump on the L1, L2, or L4 routes south (sounds like L4 would be best as it'd drop you right north of your preferred exit). You could also exit at Farragut North where you'd be in walking distance, as well as having access to the L2, D6, and 42/43, which all run past that area and go through Dupont.
I also take metro to Dupont South for work. I have asthma, and two bum knees (two knee surgeries allow me to walk, but stairs up or down are a painful b*tch). I have to figure out what I will do come Feb 1st. I was thinking of driving in on the 1st and parking at one of the three garages on 20th street, or getting off at Farragut North and walking the extra blocks to Dupont South. My thought though is, if I have to do all this extra work... why am I paying for metro? I mean they want to raise the rates, and nobody is getting raises in their incomes and are getting less and less service and rude service, if any at all from metro. I may just opt to drive from now on. I hate driving, but at this point, I am hating metro even more.
That Medical Center station manager advised me to get on the J bus. Huh? Here's a news flash, Metro; those of us who take the subway know nothing about the bus schedules. The man with the cane from Bethesda was there, too and he was as puzzled as I was. I looked at all the bus bays and found no J bus or its schedule. No one from Metro was at the street level to assist. I have no idea if the handicapped man would find his way back to Bethesda where he was headed for a doctor's appointment. I saw a bus with Friendship Heights on it and asked the driver if the bus went to Bethesda Station. He said yes, but when I got on he demanded the fare. He pointed out that I did not board a Metro bus, but a Ride-On. Oops. The buses are not painted uniformly, and beside I presumed that Metro and MoCo had some sort of reciprocal agreement to board each others' passengers when there was a station emergency, oh, but wait, Metro was not yet admitting that there was any problem at Bethesda.
4 replies · active 687 weeks ago
"Here's a news flash, Metro; those of us who take the subway know nothing about the bus schedules. "

Here's a news flash: Metro's not a subway, and many of those who ride it know the bus routes.
At Bethesda, Metro is indeed a subway. The point I was trying to make is that when Metro cannot provide their handicapped passenger with a way out of a station that is 10 stories down, Metro staff should at least be able to coherently form and communicate a plan for said passengers. In addition to the insult of no transport from platform to street, the handicapped should not also suffer the insult of being expected to figure out the bus system.
Anon20009's avatar

Anon20009 · 687 weeks ago

I think the lesson Metro Rail treaches us over and over is that everybody, special needs or not, should alwys have a Plan B. Learn the bus system, at least as relates to our typical trips, so when this very type of F--- Up by Metro happens, you will know what some options are without relying on hapless Metro personnel. Yes, absolutely, the agency should be better at helping customers but we know that won't happen, while we all know what WILL happen - SNAFUs at any unexpected moment. It's the only defense the riders have.
Anyway, I finally got to my warm office three blocks from Bethesda Station, and it only took an hour and $1.70 to MoCo. I hope that the handicapped man fared as well. To their credit, all four of the Metro employees were calm and polite, but none were willing to do anything except the bare minimum. It does chill my spine a little. What if there was a fire in Bethesda Station? How do handicapped people get out then? Metro Rail's advice, "Backtrack to the last station and hop on a bus", seems a bit insufficient and dismissive.

Here's the email waiting for me from Metro: Bethesda: All entrance escalators are out of service due to a mechanical problem. Buses have been requested, the station remains open.

Nice, but too little, too late. Passengers needed an announcement while in the station. And again, at what station were these mythical buses to be found?
One word: Pathetic...
If Metro was able to collect the fares that its employees were apparently stealing, maybe they could have ensured the elevator was functioning... http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/crime-scene/p...
1 reply · active 687 weeks ago
Yeah, I was wondering what everyone thought about that. Sad thing is Jackie Jeter will accuse everyone of being racist and get them their jobs back.
MadAsHeck's avatar

MadAsHeck · 687 weeks ago

Dear Mr. Sarles, Ms. Jeter, Mr. Stessel.

I have a challenge for you: tomorrow, wear a blindfold and try to make your way to work using the Metro. When you find yourself stuck on a platform, try to find one of your employees to assist you.

Good luck! (you're gonna need it)
This is appalling. I have navigated Metro on a sprained ankle-- several times, because I'm a champ like that-- and I can tell you that the system is practically intraversible for people with any kind of disability (permanent or temporary). The unreliability of elevators and escalators renders the system completely unusable for anyone who is not fully able-bodied. The apathy of station managers doesn't do anything to alleviate this problem.

My heart goes out to Denise. I struggled to commute on a sprained ankle for a few weeks-- she has to do this every day.
hrh king friday 13's avatar

hrh king friday 13 · 687 weeks ago

Metro is inhuman. Plain and simple.
Anony Mouse's avatar

Anony Mouse · 687 weeks ago

You want Metro employees to actually do their jobs AND assist someone with special needs? Apparently, you believe in slavery!
This is unbelievable. I am sorry my kind hurt guide dogs feet sometimes. We wouldn't ever do so on purpose.

You should slap their asses with an ADA lawsuit for refusal of service.

I'm informing my bros at the Smithsonian... Jimmy Escalator #2 and Johnny #3 about this shit.

We'll try to chew that WMATA genuis' feet up for ya'!
http://metroescalator.wordpress.com
A nice fat ADA lawsuit would serve METRO well. even if we the riders end up picking up the tab.
1 reply · active 687 weeks ago
SilverSpring-Vienna's avatar

SilverSpring-Vienna · 687 weeks ago

One cannot squeeze blood from a stone. Suing WMATA won't solve anything, unless your goal is to make riding it so expensive that only the most well-paid area workers can afford it.
Stan Dessel's avatar

Stan Dessel · 687 weeks ago

We were just giving Denise extra time to enjoy the station mini renovation. As for the Metro employee, they won the lottery and are no longer at Metro.
Ever and anon's avatar

Ever and anon · 687 weeks ago

Not surprising at all. The attendants are too busy robbing us to bother clicking a button to turn the escalators on or off. By way of evidence, may I present:
http://www.wtop.com/?nid=41&sid=2712764
Workers accused of stealing thousands from Metro fare machines
Thursday - 1/19/2012, 11:52am ET

(Hey Unsuck - an email to you bounced back as nonexistent on yahoo.com.)
1 reply · active 687 weeks ago
I wonder how soon the union will get these thieves thier jobs back? (with back pay)
http://dcist.com/2012/01/steal_money_buy_lottery_...
Re the employees stealing from farecard machines, gotta love Sarles's response:

'Sarles...described it as a “betrayal to all the honest employees of Washington Metro.”'

Uh, actually, it is a betrayal of your CUSTOMERS, who are already overcharged for rides and parking, contend daily with non-functioning trains/escalators/elevators, and who are sick and tired of self-serving comments from Metro every time another management disaster comes to light.
1 reply · active 687 weeks ago
Ever Anon's avatar

Ever Anon · 687 weeks ago

"Honest employees?" You're right! That is hilarious!
I learned a few years back that as a person with movement disabilities, who sometimes needs a wheelchair, that Metro is just not reliable enough to count on as a mode of transportation. I understand that I'm privileged (somewhat) because I can usually drum up someone to take me to where I need to go; but it scares the crap out of me thinking about a day where I might need to rely on Metro, or the bus system in MoCo, to get me anywhere,
A lot of people have no empathy to help someone for whatever the reason is. Karma will get back to them someday. :)
Look at the ol' feller. He hates Metro too!

Good boy!
What can I say, except for I am sorry that you and your guide dog were treated in such a degrading, insensitive and inhumane manner. Metro continues to prove time and time again that it is clueless when dealing with passengers who need help and the riding public overall.

Sadly, Metro will not improve until the lazy, uncaring employees are replaced with those who actually enjoy working with the public and take pride in themselves and their work.
This story should be published in the Washington Post.

Post a new comment

Comments by

 
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License.
Site Meter